[mkgmap-dev] [PATCH v1] Using name-tag-list for country names

Mon Oct 10 21:43:31 BST 2011

Am 10.10.2011 22:34, schrieb Carlos Dávila:
> El 10/10/11 21:28, WanMil escribió:
>>> El 08/10/11 20:33, WanMil escribió:
>>>> Up to now the names of the countries were taken from the
>>>> LocatorConfig.xml file no matter what has been configured in the
>>>> name-tag-list option.
>>>> But the name-tag-list option was used to get the country names from
>>>> the precompiled bounds which causes a problem if country name in the
>>>> special language is not contained in the LocatorConfig.xml.
>>>>
>>>> The patch now uses the name-tag-list consistently for all places where
>>>> country names are standardized.
>>>>
>>>> Additionally the values in the LocatorConfig.xml are automatically
>>>> completed by all name tags of the precompiled boundaries.
>>>>
>>>> http://files.mkgmap.org.uk/detail/37 links to r2047 including this patch.
>>> I have tested your patch to build my India map, but get the same errors
>>> than without it, plus an new warning from LocatorConfig (see below).
>>> Additionally, LocationHook errors with patched mkgmap show names in
>>> local languages, despite the use of name-tag-list=int_name,name:en,name
>> Carlos,
>> it seems that mkgmap does not have access to a LocatorConfig.xml. The
>> countries listed in your log are contained in the LocatorConfig.xml
>> provided with mkgmap so they should be found.
>> Did you modify the LocatorConfig.xml file?
> No, I use the one from trunk. Within the jar file it's placed in the
> root directory. I extracted it from the jar and is exactly the same that
> the one in trunk.
> Looking in other logs I see something is going wrong also with other
> countries. For example, compiling Spain I get warnings about "Algérie"
> and "Andorra" which are also in LocatorConfig, but not about Spain,
> Portugal or France.

Can you please test it without any modifications to the LocatorConfig? 
So please remove all LocatorConfig.xml files in your mkgmap environment 
so that only the one that is provided with the mkgmap build can be used.

Bye the way: if you want to compile maps for the region India it might 
be a good idea to fix the boundary of India and Pakistan. They are 
broken and are not contained in any precompiled boundary.

>>> patched mkgmap log:
>>> 2011/10/09 22:31:02 ADVERTENCIA (LocatorConfig): 55180002.osm.pbf:
>>> Cannot find country with tags [name:de=Myanmar;
>>> mkgmap:boundaryid=r50371; name:ru=Мьянма; name:sv=Myanmar;
>>> admin_level=2; name:sk=Mjanmarsko; name:sl=Mjanmar; name:en=Burma;
>>> ISO3166-1=mm; name:fr=Birmanie; type=boundary; boundary=administrative;
>>> name:es=Myanmar; name=ပြည်ထောင်စုမြန်မာနိုင်ငံတော်‌]
>>> 2011/10/09 22:31:02 GRAVE (LocationHook): 55180002.osm.pbf: Country name
>>> ပြည်ထောင်စုမြန်မာနိုင်ငံတော်‌ not in locator config. Country may not be
>>> assigned correctly.
>>> 2011/10/09 22:31:02 ADVERTENCIA (LocatorConfig): 55180002.osm.pbf:
>>> Cannot find country with tags [name:de=Bangladesch;
>>> mkgmap:boundaryid=r184640; name:ru=Бангладеш; name:sv=Bangladesh;
>>> admin_level=2; name:sk=Bangladéš; name:sl=Bangladeš; name:en=Bangladesh;
>>> ISO3166-1=bd; type=boundary; name:hu=Banglades; boundary=administrative;
>>> name:es=Bangladesh; name=বাংলাদেশ]
>>> 2011/10/09 22:31:02 GRAVE (LocationHook): 55180002.osm.pbf: Country name
>>> বাংলাদেশ not in locator config. Country may not be assigned correctly.
>>> 2011/10/09 22:31:02 ADVERTENCIA (LocatorConfig): 55180002.osm.pbf:
>>> Cannot find country with tags [name:de=Sri Lanka; name:ru=Шри-Ланка;
>>> admin_level=2; ISO3166-1=lk; name:en=Sri Lanka; boundary=administrative;
>>> name=ශ්‍රී ලංකා; name:fr=Sri Lanka; border_type=nation; type=boundary;
>>> mkgmap:boundaryid=r536807]
>>> 2011/10/09 22:31:02 GRAVE (LocationHook): 55180002.osm.pbf: Country name
>>> ශ්‍රී ලංකා not in locator config. Country may not be assigned correctly.
>>> 2011/10/09 22:31:02 ADVERTENCIA (LocationHook): 55180002.osm.pbf: Cannot
>>> process boundary element because it contains no name and no zip tag.
>>> [mkgmap:lies_in=2:r536807; addr:city=Nittambuwa; is_in:country=Sri
>>> Lanka; place=village; boundary=administrative; is_in=Gampaha; Western
>>> Province; Sri Lanka; landuse=residential; border_type=village;
>>> mkgmap:boundaryid=w49967688]
>>> 2011/10/09 22:31:02 ADVERTENCIA (LocatorConfig): 55180002.osm.pbf:
>>> Cannot find country with tags [name:de=Indonesien;
>>> mkgmap:boundaryid=r304751; name:ru=Индонезия; name:sv=Indonesien;
>>> admin_level=2; ISO3166-1=id; name:en=Indonesia; type=multipolygon;
>>> name:fr=Indonésie; boundary=administrative; name=Indonesia;
>>> border_type=nation; name:es=Indonesia]
>>> 2011/10/09 22:31:02 GRAVE (LocationHook): 55180002.osm.pbf: Country name
>>> Indonesia not in locator config. Country may not be assigned correctly.
>>>
>>> trunk log:
>>> 2011/10/09 22:26:34 GRAVE (LocationHook): 55180002.osm.pbf: Country name
>>> Burma not in locator config. Country may not be assigned correctly.
>>> 2011/10/09 22:26:34 GRAVE (LocationHook): 55180002.osm.pbf: Country name
>>> Bangladesh not in locator config. Country may not be assigned correctly.
>>> 2011/10/09 22:26:34 GRAVE (LocationHook): 55180002.osm.pbf: Country name
>>> Sri Lanka not in locator config. Country may not be assigned correctly.
>>> 2011/10/09 22:26:34 ADVERTENCIA (LocationHook): 55180002.osm.pbf: Cannot
>>> process boundary element because it contains no name and no zip tag.
>>> [mkgmap:lies_in=2:r536807; addr:city=Nittambuwa; is_in:country=Sri
>>> Lanka; place=village; boundary=administrative; is_in=Gampaha; Western
>>> Province; Sri Lanka; landuse=residential; border_type=village;
>>> mkgmap:boundaryid=w49967688]
>>> 2011/10/09 22:26:34 GRAVE (LocationHook): 55180002.osm.pbf: Country name
>>> Indonesia not in locator config. Country may not be assigned correctly.
>
> _______________________________________________
> mkgmap-dev mailing list
> mkgmap-dev at lists.mkgmap.org.uk
> http://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev