[mkgmap-dev] highway=track with no road_class and road_speed set breaks routing ## was ## "No roads near target" bug in Schwabmünchen

Mon Apr 8 19:59:41 BST 2013

Hi Gerd,

I did some tests with the mkgmap versions you provided.

the change must have entered between 2460 and 2467.
also it does not seem to be x-housenumbers related.

I created maps using just this one tile that contains the test area
(each gmapsupp.img is only about 13MB)
I could zip them if you like.
I used the default mkgmap style with the modified tracks-line, the one
with no road_class.

I tested on the Oregon and the Nüvi
I set the current position to Mittelstetten Dorfstraße / Jägerweg and
tried routing to the POI "Schönwetter Automobile" and
"Robert-Bosch-Straße 14" in Schwabmünchen.

Strange enough, routing to the address is broken even in 2460, but I
could have sworn it worked when I made my first post.

here's the results:

MKGMAP Version 	Housenumbers 	Target 	Device 	Result
2460 	x-housenumbers 	POI Schönwetter 	Nüvi 	OK
2460 	x-housenumbers 	ADDRESS Robert-Bosch-Str 14 	Nüvi 	BUG using non
existant way
2467 	x-housenumbers 	POI Schönwetter 	Nüvi 	BUG using non existant way
2467 	x-housenumbers 	ADDRESS Robert-Bosch-Str 14 	Nüvi 	BUG using non
existant way

2460 	no-housenumbers 	POI Schönwetter 	Nüvi 	OK
2460 	no-housenumbers 	POI Schönwetter 	Oregon 	OK
2460 	no-housenumbers 	ADDRESS Robert-Bosch-Str 14 	Nüvi 	BUG using non
existant way
2460 	no-housenumbers 	ADDRESS Robert-Bosch-Str 14 	Oregon 	BUG no roads
near target
2467 	no-housenumbers 	POI Schönwetter 	Nüvi 	BUG using non existant way
2467 	no-housenumbers 	POI Schönwetter 	Oregon 	BUG no roads near target
2467 	no-housenumbers 	ADDRESS Robert-Bosch-Str 14 	Nüvi 	BUG using non
existant way
2467 	no-housenumbers 	ADDRESS Robert-Bosch-Str 14 	Oregon 	BUG no roads
near target

Ciao,
  Franco

Am 08.04.2013 09:07, schrieb Gerd Petermann:
> Hi Franco,
>
> I still don't know what's wrong, and I can't reproduce the problem on
> my Oregon :-(
> You say that r2460 is working , but r2544 is not. I compared the
> sources of these two releases and found two major changes which might
> have an influence on the index. One came with r2468, the other with r2481.
> I've compiled five versions 2460,2467,2468,2480, and 2481 :
> |http://files.mkgmap.org.uk/download/100/mkmap_versions.zip|
> Please use these binaries and try to reproduce the problem. Let me
> know the highest version that still worked.
> Always use the same input files, esp. your style file. If you think
> that the problem is not related to the x-housenumber option, please
> disable that for all versions.
>
> Gerd

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.mkgmap.org.uk/pipermail/mkgmap-dev/attachments/20130408/fbf496cc/attachment-0001.html 