[mkgmap-dev] Name-tag-list parameter not used in relations processing

Sat Mar 29 20:54:29 GMT 2014

Selon GerdP <gpetermann_muenchen at hotmail.com>:

> Hi Paco,
>
> you can try it, I've uploaded the binary :
> http://files.mkgmap.org.uk/download/192/mkgmap.jar
>
> Gerd

Hi Gerd,
I'm afraid the patch isn't effective.

For your information, the relations file contains :

network=icn & state!=proposed {
	apply {
		set icn_from_relation=yes;
		set icn_name='${name}';
		set icn_ref='${ref}';
	};
	echotags "Relation ICN";
}

and the corresponding lines file :
highway=* & icn_from_relation=yes  {name '${icn_ref}
(${icn_name|not-equal:icn_ref})' | '${icn_ref}'; echotags "ICN way"; }  [0x00
resolution 15-15 continue]

Mkgmap r3116, without name-tag-list parameter set :
[java] 2345035 - [route=bicycle,type=route,name=EuroVelo 3 - part
France,ref=EV3,network=icn] Relation ICN
[java] 254539829 - [motorcar=yes,mkgmap:label:1=EV3 (EuroVelo 3 - part
France),mkgmap:admin_level2=FRA,mkgmap:admin_level3=France
métropolitaine,mkgmap:admin_level4=Picardie,icn_from_relation=yes,mkgmap:admin_level6=Oise,icn_ref=EV3,mkgmap:admin_level8=Pontpoint,mkgmap:admin_level7=Senlis,name=Trans'Oise,surface=paved,highway=cycleway,foot=designated,mkgmap:street=Trans'Oise,mkgmap:country=FRA,mkgmap:city=Pontpoint,icn_name=EuroVelo
3 - part
France,bicycleroute=yes,source=GPS,mkgmap:region=Picardie,toll=no,tollroad=no,bicycle=yes]
ICN way

Mkgmap r3116, name-tag-list parameter set to name:fr,name,int_name :
[java] 2345035 - [route=bicycle,type=route,name=EuroVelo 3 - part
France,name:fr=La route des pèlerins - portion France,ref=EV3,network=icn]
Relation ICN
[java] 254539829 - [motorcar=yes,mkgmap:label:1=EV3 (EuroVelo 3 - part
France),mkgmap:admin_level2=FRA,mkgmap:admin_level3=France
métropolitaine,mkgmap:admin_level4=Picardie,icn_from_relation=yes,mkgmap:admin_level6=Oise,icn_ref=EV3,mkgmap:admin_level8=Pontpoint,mkgmap:admin_level7=Senlis,name=Trans'Oise,surface=paved,highway=cycleway,foot=designated,mkgmap:street=Trans'Oise,mkgmap:country=FRA,mkgmap:city=Pontpoint,icn_name=EuroVelo
3 - part
France,bicycleroute=yes,source=GPS,mkgmap:region=Picardie,toll=no,tollroad=no,bicycle=yes]
ICN way

Mkgmap r3118, with jar file overwritten with your patched jar, without
name-tag-list-parameter:
[java] 2345035 - [route=bicycle,type=route,name=EuroVelo 3 - part
France,ref=EV3,network=icn] Relation ICN
[java] 254539829 - [motorcar=yes,mkgmap:label:1=EV3 (EuroVelo 3 - part
France),mkgmap:admin_level2=FRA,mkgmap:admin_level3=France
métropolitaine,mkgmap:admin_level4=Picardie,icn_from_relation=yes,mkgmap:admin_level6=Oise,icn_ref=EV3,mkgmap:admin_level8=Pontpoint,mkgmap:admin_level7=Senlis,name=Trans'Oise,surface=paved,highway=cycleway,foot=designated,mkgmap:street=Trans'Oise,mkgmap:country=FRA,mkgmap:city=Pontpoint,icn_name=EuroVelo
3 - part
France,bicycleroute=yes,source=GPS,mkgmap:region=Picardie,toll=no,tollroad=no,bicycle=yes]
ICN way

Mkgmap r3118, with jar file overwritten with your patched jar, name-tag-list
parameter set to name:fr,name,int_name :
[java] 2345035 - [route=bicycle,type=route,name=EuroVelo 3 - part
France,name:fr=La route des pèlerins - portion France,ref=EV3,network=icn]
Relation ICN
[java] 254539829 - [motorcar=yes,mkgmap:label:1=EV3 (EuroVelo 3 - part
France),mkgmap:admin_level2=FRA,mkgmap:admin_level3=France
métropolitaine,mkgmap:admin_level4=Picardie,icn_from_relation=yes,mkgmap:admin_level6=Oise,icn_ref=EV3,mkgmap:admin_level8=Pontpoint,mkgmap:admin_level7=Senlis,name=Trans'Oise,surface=paved,highway=cycleway,foot=designated,mkgmap:street=Trans'Oise,mkgmap:country=FRA,mkgmap:city=Pontpoint,icn_name=EuroVelo
3 - part
France,bicycleroute=yes,source=GPS,mkgmap:region=Picardie,toll=no,tollroad=no,bicycle=yes]
ICN way

What I want is to get for way 254539829 the tag "mkgmap:label:1=La route des
pèlerins - portion France". So I expect the relation to automatically get the
tag "name=La route des pèlerins - portion France".
Or did I misunderstood the way this parameter works ?