[mkgmap-dev] access_country for default style

Sat May 3 14:50:48 BST 2014

Hi Paco,

It seems that there is no consensus for the French OSM community:
http://gis.19327.n5.nabble.com/Acces-de-certaines-voies-en-France-td5804000.html

Furthermore, I'm realizing that "designated" can be associated with an
other "designated" or with an other tag important for routing.

Therefore, permissive rules would be better here and some restrictions
can be added, e.g. in "lines", depending the wanted routing.

# France (FRA)

highway=trunk & mkgmap:country=FRA     { add bicycle=no; add foot=no }
highway=cycleway & mkgmap:country=FRA  { add foot=yes }
highway=bridleway & mkgmap:country=FRA { add bicycle=yes; add foot=yes }

Do you agree with that ?

Steph

Le 03/05/2014 05:00, paco.tyson at free.fr a écrit :
> Selon Stéphane MARTIN <st3ph.martin at laposte.net>:
> 
>> Hi,
> Hi Stéphane, hi all
> 
> I reply to Stéphane but I think everyone should read and may reply as I have
> general questions.
> 
>> Does this proposal makes sense for France ?
>> According to
>>
> http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/OSM_tags_for_routing/Access-Restrictions#France
> 
> I don't understand this page as you do. I read this table as : which traffic
> mode is allowed *by default* (when the OSM way has no access tag defined, only
> the highway tag).
> 
>>
>> # France (FRA)
>>
>> highway=trunk & mkgmap:country=FRA
>>   { add bicycle=no; add foot=no }
> 
> Correct, we can duplicate this one for motorway also.
> 
>> highway=cycleway & bicycle=designated & mkgmap:country=FRA
>>   { add foot=no }
>> highway=cycleway & mkgmap:country=FRA
>>   { set mkgmap:foot=yes; }
> 
> As I explained in the beginning, the rules are :
> highway=cycleway & mkgmap:country=FRA
>   { set mkgmap:access=no; set mkgmap:bicycle=yes;}
> highway=cycleway & foot=yes & mkgmap:country=FRA
>    { set mkgmap:access=no; set mkgmap:bicycle=yes; set mkgmap:foot=yes; }
> 
> I don't even think the second rule is needed.
> 
>> highway=bridleway & horse=designated & mkgmap:country=FRA
>>   { add bicycle=no; add foot=no }
>> highway=bridleway & mkgmap:country=FRA
>>   { set mkgmap:foot=yes; set mkgmap:bicycle=yes; }
> 
> This one is tricky, I'm no horse rider but I think bridleways have no legal
> definition in France. I understand there are only paths which may be allowed to
> horse riders. I'd consider them as highway=path. But this should be discussed
> with the French OSM community, not here. So for now, let's apply the wiki table
> :
> 
> highway=bridleway & mkgmap:country=FRA
>    { set mkgmap:access=no; set mkgmap:horse=yes;}
> 
> BTW, I don't remember mkgmap:horse exists, correct ? So what should we do with
> them ?
> 
> Do we need to define rules for all the other highway tag values (primary,
> secondary, tertiary, unclassified, residential, living_street, track, footway
> and pedestrian) ? Are they handled by mkgmap by default ?