[mkgmap-dev] Routing problem on Garmin Oregon/edge with default style (and other styles)

Mon Jun 29 10:18:13 BST 2020

Update, previous version had some errors, conclusion is the same

Build date
Mkgmap
Device
Style
Pink line
Crash/Deadloop
Result
Comment
24-8-2017
r3995
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
Yes
No
Ok
r4195
Felix Hartmann
Felix Personal
?
Wrong
Felix thinks he uses this version and his own style but is not sure
16-4-2019
r4286
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
Yes
No
Ok
26-10-2019
r4323
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
Yes
No
Ok

r4358
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
Yes
No
Ok

r4359
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
Yes
No
Ok

r4360
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
This is what Ticker suspected and also Steve suggested. 4360 introduced new routing behaviour by design

r4361
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong

r4372
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong

17-11-2019
r4373
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
Yes
No
Ok
Orginally tested with jar file supplied by Jan Meisters: Thought it was oke!, still have the working img, but I cannot prove again this img was really created by that version. The Jar version of Steve creates an img that is not oke? 2nd & 3th time compile again with Jan's jar file to double check also suddenly is wrong: So I must have made a mistake in copy/paste or documenting the testresults. Conclusion 4373 is not oke
17-11-2019
r4373
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
r4374
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
r4376
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
r4379
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
6-12-2019
r4384
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
8-12-2019
r4386
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
25-1-2020
r4431
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
?
Wrong
r4479
Jan Meisters
Oregon 450
Jan Personal
No
No
Half
19-6-2020
r4551
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
19-6-2020
r4551
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Joris Personal
No
No
Half

Van: mkgmap-dev <mkgmap-dev-bounces at lists.mkgmap.org.uk> Namens Joris Bo
Verzonden: maandag 29 juni 2020 11:05
Aan: Development list for mkgmap <mkgmap-dev at lists.mkgmap.org.uk>
Onderwerp: Re: [mkgmap-dev] Routing problem on Garmin Oregon/edge with default style (and other styles)

Hi

I finished testing and it narrows down to 4360

Kind regards, Joris

Build date
Mkgmap
Device
Style
Pink line
Crash/Deadloop
Result
Comment
24-8-2017
r3995
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
Yes
No
Ok
r4195
Felix Hartmann
Felix Personal
?
Wrong
Felix thinks he uses this version and his own style but is not sure
16-4-2019
r4286
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
Yes
No
Ok
26-10-2019
r4323
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
Yes
No
Ok

r4358
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
Yes
No
Ok

r4359
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
Yes
No
Ok

r4360
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
No
Wrong
This is what Ticker suspected and also Steve suggested. 4360 introduced new routing behavior by design

r4361
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
No
Wrong

r4372
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
No
Wrong

17-11-2019
r4373
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
Yes
No
Ok
Orginally tested with jar file supplied by Jan Meisters: Thought it was oke!, still have the working img, but I cannot prove again this img was really created by that version. The Jar version of Steve creates an img that is not oke? 2nd & 3th time compile again with Jan's jar file to double check also suddenly is wrong: So I must have made a mistake in copy/paste or documenting the testresults. Conclusion 4373 is not oke
17-11-2019
r4373
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
No
Wrong
r4374
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
r4376
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
r4379
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
6-12-2019
r4384
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
8-12-2019
r4386
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
25-1-2020
r4431
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
?
Wrong
r4479
Jan Meisters
Oregon 450
Jan Personal
No
No
Half
19-6-2020
r4551
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Default 2020
No
Yes
Wrong
19-6-2020
r4551
Joris Bo
Oregon 650
Joris Personal
No
No
Half

-----Oorspronkelijk bericht-----
Van: mkgmap-dev <mkgmap-dev-bounces at lists.mkgmap.org.uk<mailto:mkgmap-dev-bounces at lists.mkgmap.org.uk>> Namens Steve Ratcliffe
Verzonden: zondag 28 juni 2020 10:22
Aan: mkgmap-dev at lists.mkgmap.org.uk<mailto:mkgmap-dev at lists.mkgmap.org.uk>
Onderwerp: Re: [mkgmap-dev] Routing problem on Garmin Oregon/edge with default style (and other styles)

Hi Joris

> Based on the versions supplied I could bring it down to 4373 still being  > OK and 4384 reveals the problem

Thanks for narrowing it down.

There was a large change not long before that in version 4360 with the merge of the NET-no-NOD branch that did affect the routing a lot.

It causes the NodCheck utility to crash, I don't know why yet.

I've put all precompiled jar files at: http://www.mkgmap.org.uk/jars/

Steve

_______________________________________________

mkgmap-dev mailing list

mkgmap-dev at lists.mkgmap.org.uk<mailto:mkgmap-dev at lists.mkgmap.org.uk>

http://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://www.mkgmap.org.uk/pipermail/mkgmap-dev/attachments/20200629/624ebdb4/attachment-0001.html>